Best E-Reader for Someone Who Reads Textbooks AND Novels
For Whom/What:
grad student, heavy annotator
Budget:
$150-350
Requirements:
Handles PDFs without reformatting issues
good for handwritten notes
battery lasts multiple days
Extra Details:
: Torn between a Kindle Scribe and a reMarkable. Everyone who owns either seems weirdly loyal to theirs, so trying to get past the fanboy reviews to what actually works day to day.
Kindle Scribe, but only if you're being honest about how much annotating you actually do versus how much you think you'll do.
I read PDFs of dense academic stuff and also just want to read fiction before bed without switching devices, and this handles both fine. Handwriting notes directly on PDFs is genuinely useful for textbook margins instead of maintaining a separate notes app that you'll never open again. Battery easily lasts a week of normal use.
The reMarkable is beautiful and probably better if you're a pure note-taker, but it's not really built for casual novel reading the way the Kindle side of the Scribe is. If you're doing both like the question asks, Scribe wins on versatility even if it's not the best at either single thing.
Best E-Reader for Someone Who Reads Textbooks AND Novels
grad student, heavy annotator
$150-350
Handles PDFs without reformatting issues
good for handwritten notes
battery lasts multiple days
: Torn between a Kindle Scribe and a reMarkable. Everyone who owns either seems weirdly loyal to theirs, so trying to get past the fanboy reviews to what actually works day to day.
Kindle Scribe, but only if you're being honest about how much annotating you actually do versus how much you think you'll do.
I read PDFs of dense academic stuff and also just want to read fiction before bed without switching devices, and this handles both fine. Handwriting notes directly on PDFs is genuinely useful for textbook margins instead of maintaining a separate notes app that you'll never open again. Battery easily lasts a week of normal use.
The reMarkable is beautiful and probably better if you're a pure note-taker, but it's not really built for casual novel reading the way the Kindle side of the Scribe is. If you're doing both like the question asks, Scribe wins on versatility even if it's not the best at either single thing.